Heritage Auctions
Historical News
In This Issue:
The Wide Awakes
Political Cartoons in the United States
Fascinating Phrenology
Upcoming Auction Highlights
Around Heritage Auctions
Time To Sell?
Current Auctions

October 5, 2022
The Wide Awakes
By Ray Farina

Most collectors of 19th century political memorabilia and historians acquainted with American political campaign history are aware of the 1860 political marching club known as the Wide Awakes. We are familiar with the basic tenets by which they operated. For instance, the Wide Awakes was a Republican derived paramilitary marching club supporting Abraham Lincoln and all Republican candidates in their districts. The Wide Awakes were comprised of young white men ranging in age from their teens to their thirties, who by embracing new political attitudes sought to attract younger and ambitious participants looking to proclaim themselves as the voices of the younger voter. Many of us also know that their structured highly competitive military style was comprised of officers and soldiers holding military ranks and engaged in specific duties, among which was to protect Republican Party speakers in hostile Democratic-friendly towns and cities. Also, the Wide Awakes were visibly present at the polls to ensure protection and peaceful engagement of the general public participating in the voting process.

Abraham Lincoln: Belfast, Maine, Wide Awake Parade Banner
Abraham Lincoln: Belfast, Maine, Wide Awake Parade Banner
Abraham Lincoln: Amazing Pair of Wide Awake Parade Finials
Abraham Lincoln:
Amazing Pair of Wide
Awake Parade Finials
Beyond these commonly acknowledged understandings not much is generally discussed respective to the significant social and cultural impacts of the Wide Awakes. There is much more to their story!

Most of the “soldiers” comprising the Wide Awakes were born between the administrations of John Quincy Adams and William Henry Harrison. They came of age during the bitter tensions of sectionalism. Some were old enough to participate in the Mexican War, they saw divisiveness result from the Compromise of 1850, and conflict from the Kansas-Nebraska Act. They realized that their political system was failing them and it did not help that the country was losing its greatest elder statesmen. The Wide Awakes saw their mission to take up the mantle and continue the good works of these prominent politicians and visionaries like Daniel Webster and Henry Clay. Their “eyes were wide open” to the need for change, and to right the political wrongs of the past. They adopted the “all-seeing-eye” as their symbol for a new awakening of political philosophy and direction.

The young and aggressive militarism of the Wide Awakes was not lost on the South in 1860. The fierce appearance of these young northerners, many with beards and goatees, dressed in uniforms with military caps and black capes, carrying torches, painted wood axes, and marching in the middle of the night terrified southerners who saw their tactics as an ominous signal of what may lie in store for them from this new radical Republican Party and their anti-southern attitudes.

Abraham Lincoln: Wide Awake Marcher Wooden Parade Ax
Abraham Lincoln: Wide Awake Marcher Wooden Parade Ax
The Wide Awakes, though its beginnings were rooted in Connecticut, quickly proliferated throughout the country from Maine, Vermont, New York, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New Jersey, and New Hampshire westward to Ohio, Illinois, Iowa, Indiana, and other parts of the Midwest thus becoming a national organization. Using popular social events as opportunities to expand their ranks they appealed to those seeking the camaraderie of a fraternal organization, and even had comic books to promote themselves! The illustrated pamphlet, “Pipps Among the Wide Awakes” was a deliberate appeal to young voters to join up. Twenty-one-year-old Pipps grows a moustache and declares his independence from parental controls and their old-fashioned political ideals. Vowing to cast his first vote for Lincoln and exercise his freedoms he declares himself a “Man of the World and a Politician.” Pipps decides that participating in a political campaign is the most important thing a man can do to affirm his masculinity and maturity! Pipps’ story had a definite appeal to young northerners who truly believed they represented a new generation of astute, politically-minded men no longer chained to the indoctrinations of past party politics or generational beliefs. The Wide Awakes enabled this transformation. Their use of militarism for political purposes was crafty but dangerous and although Captains in the organization used friendly rivalries as a means of engaging and motivating various units around the country, the Wide Awakes maintained a martial seriousness to their mission that separated them from other political clubs of the day.

Abraham Lincoln: Large Mounted Salt Print of New Haven Wide Awakes with Bonus
Abraham Lincoln: Large Mounted
Salt Print of New Haven
Wide Awakes with Bonus
Bloodshed and violence were also an unintentional (perhaps) consequence of the Wide Awakes style of political expression. Repercussions from the Democratic opposition often resulted in heated exchanges of brutal attacks with stones, bricks, and even torches used as weapons. People got hurt. Generally speaking when these fights broke out the Wide Awakes never fought like a military unit, they broke ranks and fought individually against their opponents. One New York Company of Wide Awakes when asked about their brutal brawls complained the torch handles made from pine tended to splinter “after just a few blows to the head.” Things were far worse out in the Midwest where these vicious encounters often resulted in gunfire and stabbings.

The irony resulting from the Wide Awakes militaristic approach and their constant insistence that they were peaceful and well-intentioned was often questioned by those who believed that if you dress and act like a military unit how can you expect anyone to consider your intentions as non-violent? South of the Mason-Dixon line Democratic politicians were convinced that the Wide Awakes were cultivating an army that would at some point advance upon them prepared for war.

Abraham Lincoln: 'Charlotte Wide Awake Girls' Ribbon
Abraham Lincoln: "Charlotte Wide Awake Girls" Ribbon
Despite the fear and loathing generated by the Wide Awakes among southern factions, they were endeared to and appreciated by northern supporters and especially by the ladies! Their efficiency in performing intricate drills during parades along with their handsome uniforms made for a compelling presentation that any ardent female Republican supporter could admire and take pride in. One Wide Awake diarist in Ohio noted, “The ladies, bless them, stayed and cheered us with their presence till we were through, and they were as good looking a company of women as one will see.”

At the height of their ranks the Wide Awakes were comprised of perhaps 100,000 youth in number, maybe slightly more. Some say it was exponentially higher but there is little to prove that assertion. One thing is clear however, the Wide awakes had a significant impact on the generational and cultural changes that dominated politics and social intercourse in 1860 and beyond. Not to mention the benefits that were provided to the newly formed Republican Party and particularly the political campaign of Lincoln and Hamlin! One last sobering thought to reflect upon is, intended or not, the exemplification of the Wide Awakes presented an apparitional foreshadowing of the dark and bloody days to come.

Back to Top

Political Cartoons in the United States
By Curtis Lindner

When one hears the word “cartoon” most think of the Saturday morning shows we all watched (if you’re my age) as a child. But in the world of political collecting, what comes to mind is much different. It is thought that Benjamin Franklin published and created the first political cartoon in his newspaper the Pennsylvania Gazette, which he acquired in 1729. In May of 1754, he published the cartoon “Join or Die,” which promoted the idea of “Union”. The cartoon pictured pieces of a snake’s body, which was being compared to the colonies in the fledging country. Many know this famous rendering, which has been used and reprinted throughout the history of the United States.

Today collecting political cartoons has become very popular, especially examples published by Currier & Ives from the mid-19th century. Some of the more popular candidates included Andrew Jackson, William Henry Harrison and John Quincy Adams. Cartoons from the 1860 and 1864 campaigns featuring Abraham Lincoln have really taken off with popularity, likely due to the political issues that were facing the country at that time. These cartoons pictured the candidates, usually containing issues from their campaign platforms….some anti and some pro. Many were satirical in nature, and all are fascinating to view and read.

As mentioned in the previous paragraph the majority of cartoons are theme based, and feature issues pertaining to the current presidential race. One of my favorites is from the 1860 campaign, and is titled “The National Game. Three “Outs” and One “Run”. Abraham Winning the Ball”. The four presidential candidates are portrayed, each wearing a belt with the name of his respective team (political party) and each carrying a bat indicating his political program or platform. Lincoln seems to be on the verge of winning the contest as he stands on "Home Base" and dispenses advice to his losing opponents on how to succeed in this game. Many baseball metaphors are utilized in the balloon captions. My favorite is Douglas's comment to Bell: "That's because he had that confounded rail to strike with. I thought our fusion would be a 'short stop' to his career." The game of baseball was fairly new, and using that theme in a political cartoon makes this especially desirable, plus the piece is hand colored, which is rarely encountered.

Abraham Lincoln: Fantastic Baseball Themed Currier & Ives Cartoon
Abraham Lincoln: Fantastic Baseball
Themed Currier & Ives Cartoon
Another fantastic example comes from the 1836 presidential contest, which is titled “Political race Course – Union Track – Fall Races 1836”. It shows the four candidates of 1836 as race horses, with the heads of William Henry Harrison, Martin Van Buren, Daniel Webster and Hugh White. A frontiersman rides the Harrison horse who is in the lead and appears heading for victory. Jackson rides the Van Buren steed. The jockeys make pithy comments on the progress of the race, the qualities (or lack thereof) of their mounts and their prospects for winning the race. Very little in the way of campaign material was issued in the election of 1836. Again, a rare example, this cartoon is printed in color.

William Henry Harrison: Phenomenal 1836 Cartoon
William Henry Harrison: Phenomenal 1836 Cartoon
Another favorite of mine is based on the Union versus the Confederacy picturing Abraham Lincoln fighting Jefferson Davis titled “Caving In, Or A Rebel “Deeply Humiliated”. Likely published in 1862, Abraham Lincoln is seen getting the best of Jefferson Davis in this boxing match. Old Abe has delivered several blows to Davis landing many punches judged by the confederate losses listed about Davis' head and shoulders. Lincoln is shown having taken hits at Bull Run and the Battle of Big Bethel, both in 1861. Foreign dignitaries look on in wonderment, speculating as to results of the Civil War. This cartoon is rich with the goings on in the early days of the Civil War.

Abraham Lincoln: Cartoon 'Caving In, Or A Rebel 'Deeply Humiliated.'' A Boxing Contest
Abraham Lincoln: Cartoon "Caving In,
Or A Rebel 'Deeply Humiliated.'" A Boxing Contest
This is just a small representation of the many varieties of political drawing and cartoons that were published during the 19th Century. Moreover, artists have continued to express and publish their political opinions in this amusing and interesting format even to this day. Those who are already collecting political cartoons, or have an interest in assembling a collection, will certainly have a wide variety to choose from. It’s no wonder that hobby engagement remains high in this educational and a fun segment of political campaign collecting. Happy Hunting!

Back to Top

Fascinating Phrenology
By Laurel Witt

Perhaps you’ve heard of palm reading, but what about skull reading? Though now considered a pseudoscience, phrenology, the practice of correlating one’s character with the physical aspects of one’s cranium, was particularly influential during the nineteenth century. Originally developed in Europe by Franz Joseph Gall, it was believed that the brain’s form was revealed through the skull’s particular shape. A personal profile of temperaments, strengths, and weaknesses could be revealed by studying and measuring its features. Different regions of the skull bore designated traits, so depending on the bump's placement, one's head could determine anything from one's self-esteem to personal desires.

Johann Spurzheim and brothers George and Andrew Combe would help further the research of phrenology and bring it to the United States. It was specifically George Combe’s work, Constitution of Man, that inspired American brothers Orson and Lorenzo Fowler to not only begin publishing the American Phrenological Journal but to “read” thousands of heads, including those of famous personalities, including Mark Twain and Clara Barton. A scathing political cartoon available in our DeWitt sale published by H.R. Robinson features Orson S. Fowler, measuring the head of Zachary Taylor with a caliper and declaring him “incompetent.” A poster behind Fowler to the left advertises “Fowler & Wells,” referencing Samuel R. Wells, who later joined the brothers, forming the publishing house of Fowler and Wells.

[Lewis Cass] Anti-Zachary Taylor Phrenological Cartoon
[Lewis Cass] Anti-Zachary Taylor Phrenological Cartoon
Fowler and Wells often utilized engraved images to provide insight into an individual’s personality by including a reading of facial features. Arguably, this very concept may have assisted Abraham Lincoln in his campaign for the 1864 presidency due to the massive number of photographs printed and sold to the public featuring his portrait. According to Fowler and Well’s brand of phrenology, anyone with a picture of Lincoln could glimpse into the core of his very character, meaning potential voters could share a more intimate bond with the presidential candidate.

In the fortieth volume (number four and whole number 310) of the American Phrenological Journal and Life Illustrated, also available in the upcoming DeWitt sale, a nice-sized image of Abraham Lincoln appears on the cover. His portrait is accompanied by an assessment of his phrenological character gained by “our portrait of Mr. Lincoln…from a recent photograph by Brady..." The article includes descriptions of his facial features and addresses different regions of his skull. Whereas his lips indicated “affection, wit, and playfulness…,” the largest of the “perceptive faculties” seen in his forehead are Individuality, Form, Size, Order, Eventuality, and Locality. Overall—a very flattering reading!

Abraham Lincoln: Pair of Periodicals
Abraham Lincoln: Pair of Periodicals
Though phrenology’s popularity significantly waned by the end of the nineteenth century, there are modern imitations of the graphically interesting paraphernalia, particularly the busts that could range from a plain ceramic glaze to colorfully painted and even gilded. Other collectibles include phrenological journals, craniometers, charts, cartoons, and more—it’s only appropriate to assume a display of this “caliper” would yield the most character.

Back to Top

Upcoming Auction Highlights
Highlights from The J. Doyle Dewitt Collection Part II Americana & Political Signature Auction
Highlights from The J. Doyle Dewitt Collection Part II Americana & Political Signature® Auction

October 15 - 16 The J. Doyle Dewitt Collection Part II Americana & Political Signature Auction #6266
October 15 - 16 The J. Doyle Dewitt Collection Part II Americana & Political Signature® Auction #6266

William Henry Harrison: Large 1840 Silk Campaign Bandana
William Henry Harrison: Large 1840 Silk Campaign Bandana
John C. Frémont: Tremendous Folk Art Banner
John C. Frémont: Tremendous
Folk Art Banner
[Confederate States] Huge First National Flag with Inspiring Motto
[Confederate States] Huge First National Flag with Inspiring Motto
George Washington: Personally-Owned Coat Buttons
George Washington:
Personally-Owned Coat Buttons


October 19 Historic African Americana Signature Auction #6248
October 19 Historic African
Americana Signature® Auction #6248

Poems on Various Subjects, Religious and Moral by Phillis Wheatley
Poems on Various Subjects, Religious and Moral by Phillis Wheatley
'I Am a Man' Triptych Set of Posters
"I Am a Man" Triptych Set of Posters
Henry A. Wallace 'Jim Crow is His Enemy' Campaign Poster
Henry A. Wallace "Jim Crow is His Enemy" Campaign Poster
Frederick Douglass Ambrotype
Frederick Douglass Ambrotype


November 30 Texana Signature® Auction #6264

December 3 - 4 Seeley Family Presidential Christmas Collection Americana & Political Signature® Auction #6263

December 3 Vintage Casino Chips Americana & Political Signature® Auction #6270

Back to Top

Around Heritage Auctions
Julian Onderdonk. Spring Twilight, Bluebonnets, 1917
Paintings by Onderdonk and Salinas, Sculptures by Umlauf Lead Heritage's October Texas Art Auction

There are two things to keep in mind while pondering the term "Texas Art." One is that Texas art encompasses so many decades, sensibilities and mediums that it's impossible to reduce it to "Western" themes. The second thing to remember, conversely, is that sometimes Texas art indeed evokes subjects and themes that are quintessentially Texan or Western. This dichotomy is the beauty of a category that's both sweeping and intimate for followers of Texas art: Texas-based artists are never limited by geography, but they don't necessarily attempt to dodge it, either.

In this respect, Heritage's upcoming Texas Art Signature® Auction feels something like a homecoming. This is a return to familiar names and subjects that have lit up this category since the early 1900s, when Julian Onderdonk pitched his plein air easel out in Texas Hill Country to apply a bit of Impressionism's light play to the region's bluebonnets. Onderdonk and his father Robert Jenkins Onderdonk both have works in this auction: Julian's signature bluebonnets are well represented here by several outstanding paintings, including Spring Twilightfrom 1917; Robert's oil painting Shore to Shore is taken from a steel engraving printed by Clarence M. Dobell in the 1870s.

In fact, after several years of the uncertainty brought by the pandemic, this auction feels like a return to "normal" for Texas art. What has been lost these last few years, and what can we rediscover by returning to the work of our beloved mainstays: Umlauf, Salinas, the Onderdonk family, Alexandre Hogue, Dickson Reeder, George Grammer… we embrace these names and their works because they've captured something timeless and crucial about our place on this land. We yearn for the permanence that even contemporary Texas artists like David Bates and Benito Huerta find in their explorations of this frontier and its inhabitants.

Read the full press release here.

More information about American, Texas, Western, California Art.

Back to Top

William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy with Harlan Ellison - Star Trek Signed Photo (c. 1966-1969)
In Heritage's Harlan Ellison Auction, Original Art From Some of the Author's Most Famous Works and the World's Most (In)famous 'Star Trek' Photo

Upon Harlan Ellison's death in June 2018 at the age of 84, The New York Times described him as "a furiously prolific and cantankerous writer whose science fiction and fantasy stories reflected a personality so intense that they often read as if he were punching his manual typewriter keys with his fists." The tagline for the 2008 documentary about Ellison, Dreams with Sharp Teeth, described him as "Genius. Monster. Legend."

Ellison — author of classics, collector of awards, reviewer of films and comics and television shows, maker of trouble — did nothing to disabuse fans and followers of his reputation. In the introduction to the first episode of his short-form Harlan Ellison's Watching, made in the mid-1990s for the Sci-Fi Channel, he said that if you call him a writer of science fiction, "I'll come to your house, and I'll nail your pet's head to a coffee table. I'll hit you so hard your ancestors will die. I'll hit you so hard your grandmother will bleed. I'm a writer. There's no adjective in front of it. I'm just a writer."

Ellison was many things, but he was hardly just a writer, just as Frank Sinatra wasn't just a singer or Albert Einstein wasn't just a guy who was good at math. He counted among his thousands of short stories, teleplays (for The Outer Limits and The Twilight Zone, among others), screenplays, books, essays, reviews and comic-book stories some of the most enlightening, terrifying and thrilling speculative fiction ever written. Speculative because he hated "science fiction."

Read the full press release here.

More information about Comics, Comic Art & Animation Art Auctions.

Back to Top

1821 $5 BD-1, JD-1, R.8 as a proof, PR65 Cameo PCGS. CAC
1821 Half Eagle Soars to $4.6 Million, Leading First Bass Collection Auction to $20.5 Million at Heritage Auctions

A magnificent 1821 half eagle rode a burst of furiously competitive bidding all the way to $4.62 million, leading one of the finest collections of U.S. gold coins and related patterns ever assembled to $20,459,645 in Heritage Auctions' Harry W. Bass Jr. Core Collection Part I US Coins Signature® Auction - Long Beach Sept. 29.

Proceeds from the auction will benefit the dozens of Dallas-based nonprofits supported by the Harry W. Bass Jr. Foundation, with a particular emphasis on early childhood education and literacy in Dallas.

"The Bass Trustees are thrilled with the results and grateful to the Heritage Auctions team for its outstanding execution of this sale" said David Calhoun, executive director of the Harry Bass Foundation. "It was an exciting event that far exceeded our expectation." Many lots in the auction set new auction records, including:

The 1821 Capped Head Left Five, PR65 Cameo: $4,620,000 (previous record: $198,000)
An 1854 Gold Dollar, PR65 Deep Cameo: $720,000 (previous record: $68,750)
An 1833 Quarter Eagle, PR63 Cameo: $408,000 (previous record: $50,600)
An 1860-S Three Dollar Gold, MS64: $360,000 (previous record: $37,600)
An 1855-S Three Dollar, MS64: $264,000 (previous record: $64,625)

The event generated perfect sell-through rates of 100% by value and by lots sold. The lineage of many of the coins in this auction can be traced to the heralded auction of Louis E. Eliasberg Sr.'s gold coin collection in 1982.

Read the full press release here.

More information about Rare Coin Auctions.

Back to Top

Is It Time To Sell? - Consign Now!
Interested in Selling Rare Americana and Political Collectibles?

We are currently welcoming consignments for our upcoming Americana Signature® auction. Heritage is the world’s largest collectibles auctioneer, with over $1.4 billion in sales last year alone. We look forward to working with you to showcase your items at one of our prestigious Signature auction events.

Generous Cash Advances Available

We offer generous cash advances for qualifying consignments and are available nearly as soon as we receive your items. To support our growing sales volume, we also purchase a few duplicates, or even whole collections. Heritage purchases $2 million to $5 million in collectibles every week, and more when we can. We are committed to paying fair and competitive prices to acquire the material we need to meet demand from our customers. Your information will remain confidential.

Please contact one of our Americana and Political Specialists today:

Curtis Lindner
Curtis Lindner
Consignment Director,
Americana & Political
CurtisL@HA.com
800-872-6467 ext. 1352
Ray Farina
Ray Farina
Consignment Director
RayF@HA.com
800-872-6467 ext. 1135


Back to Top

Current Auctions
Historical Auctions
October 15 - 16 The J. Doyle Dewitt Collection Part II Americana & Political Signature Auction
October 15 - 16 The J. Doyle Dewitt
Collection Part II Americana &
Political Signature® Auction

View Lots
countdownmail.com
October 19 Historic African Americana Signature® Auction
October 19 Historic
African Americana
Signature® Auction

View Lots
countdownmail.com
Thursday Natural History
October 6 Thursday Natural History
Live session @ 8PM CT

View Lots
countdownmail.com
Signature Auctions
Urban Art - October 5
Long Beach Expo US Currency - October 5 - 7
Heroes & More Memorabilia Comics & Comic Art - October 6
Autumn Luxury Accessories - October 6
Long Beach Expo US Coins - October 6 - 9
Illustration Art - October 7
A Special Collection of Cuban Banknotes - October 9
Error Coinage US Coins - October 10
Modern Collectible US Coins & Bullion - October 10
Photographs - October 11
Depth of Field: Photographs - October 12
An Exclusive Polished Melee Auction - October 12
Fine & Decorative Arts - October 13
The Fiction House - October 13
The Ages of Sega Video Games - October 13
Alan Kessler Collection Ethnographic Art - October 14
The Louis Rose Collection Error Currency - October 16
Bust Coinage US Coins - October 17
World Paper Money - October 20
Harlan Ellison Comics & Comic Art - October 21
Texas Art - October 22
Sports - October 22
Historical Scholar Showcase, Part II - October 23
Prints & Multiples - October 26
Prints & Multiples Showcase - October 27
Coming Out in Comics - October 27
Halloween Pre-Code Horror and Crime Comics - October 27 - 28
Modern World Coins - October 30
Attractively Toned Coins US Coins - October 31
Lakewood Estate - November 1
Ozark Mountains Estate Auction - November 15
Weekly Auctions
Weekly US Coins - October 4 - 5
Wed. Comic Art & Animation Art - October 5
Wed. Trading Card Games - October 5
Weekly World Coin - October 5 - 6
Sun. Sports - October 9
Sun. Movie Posters - October 9
Weekly Comics - October 9 - 10
Tues. Jewelry - October 11
Tues. US Currency - October 11
Tues. World Currency - October 11
Tues. Video Games Mini-Boss - October 11
Auction Schedule | Order a Catalog
Back to Top